The Green Shoots of Recovery

Green Shoots

Here’s a great article in the April edition (Issue 129, p. 41-46) of Acoustic magazine where Bob Taylor of Taylor Guitars talks about sustainable tonewoods.

Green Shoots

In the article Bob Taylor makes some excellent observations and comments which I fully support. Here’s my selection:

there is plenty that smaller guitar manufacturers can do to promote sustainability. “Each guitar maker has the ability to do something,” he says. “If a guitar builder is large like Taylor, they should do ethical sourcing of wood and replenishing. A small luthier cannot replenish, but they can ethically source wood. One part of ethical sourcing is to care about the quality of life and the pay of the people closest to the wood. We must each know that our wood is coming from places where laws are followed and people are paid”.

Totally agree with this comment. I find it extraordinary there are so many luthiers out there more than happy to help keep plundering the worlds rainforests. Even in Tasmania and Australia this is true!

And the same goes for consumers! Please stop plundering the worlds rainforests!

If people think that growing trees is or should be charitable work, then they don’t understand sustainability at all. Are tomatoes sustainable? Of course they are, because it’s profitable to grow them. We just have to make trees profitable to grow. This will happen in many different forms, because in many industries like construction lumber or plantation teak, it is already profitable. Small operations such as our Paniolo in Hawaii, or Crelicam in Cameroon, attract attention. This magazine is interested, as are the readers, and so are some industrialists or landowners. We can· show that it can be profitable if you’re in the right situation to do so. In the case of ebony, we have to start it with investment from us, which looks like charity really, but others will be able to profit from it someday, and the sustainable cycle can start. Without selling something there is no sustainability.

But I do think it’s possible to farm guitar wood, if I can be so basic in my description.

A huge round of applause for these comments!!

That’s it! It’s all about profitable tree growing. Unless and until tree growing is profitable there will be no tonewoods in the future. Bob Taylor understands this.

That means paying higher prices than what we pay now for plundered wood.


This move [the recent CITES regulations around rosewoods] has already had an effect on Taylor’s guitars: “All the rosewoods we use will be used in lesser quantities and on more expensive guitars. Why? Because there is expense associated with using the wood and exporting and importing both the wood and the guitar. That expense for permits is the same for an expensive or a cheap guitar. Consequently, we’ll see fewer1ow-priced rosewood guitars in the market.

As rosewood is one of the major tonewoods used worldwide, this means that other species must now come into the market to replace the reduced supply of rosewood.

“no [tonewood] species now can be sustainable without a proper planting programme”.

Here in Tasmania we have no blackwood planting plan. In fact we have no blackwood plan at all. All we have is a plan to continue to plunder our public native forests using taxpayers money. For details see here:

“I often say that most guitar buyers are environmentalists, except on the day they spend their hard-earned money on their dream guitar. But I forgive them and understand. If we work together, we will find a new excitement. We are working hard to make beautiful guitars that please all the senses”.

Farm grown Tasmanian blackwood has the potential to become a profitable sustainable tonewood, but it will be a long slow road ahead under the current circumstances.

2 responses to “The Green Shoots of Recovery

  1. Hi Gordon,
    I take offence to your comment here in Tasmania we have no blackwood planting plan in fact no blackwood plan at all. All we have is a plan to continue to plunder our native forests.
    You have a chip on your shoulder Gordon please stop being so negative.
    All the blackwood I source is farm grown blackwood selectively harvested.
    All the farmers that I have worked with over the years are encouraged to replant.
    You have commented your self that on your trips around Tasmania that you have seen lots of blackwood growing on farm land and so have I and I do not see a shortage of blackwood.
    In one of your blogs you were trying to encourage farmers to export whole logs instead you should be trying to promote value adding here.
    Rosewood mahogany and other species are endangered blackwood is not exporting logs on a large scale will make it so.
    By being so negative Gordon you do not help the cause.
    I know that in Tasmania we have made many mistakes in the past but this will change, why don’t you talk to the media and politicians about a replanting program as I have done many times in the past.
    Regards Bob

  2. On another note Gordon, Bob Taylor made the comment if a guitar builder is large like Taylor, they should do ethical sourcing of wood this is why Taylor guitars do business with me as they know that my wood is sustainable sourced from private farm lands and laws are followed no rain forests are plundered. So farm blackwood guitar wood is already happening here in Tasmania and hopefully this will be used more to replace the reduced supply of rosewood and mahogany.
    Instead of making negative comments Gordon be positive good things will happen in your post you make it sound like all is bad here in Tasmania this is not the case as I am supplying sustainable tonewoods.
    Regards Bob

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s