Black Friday

Last Friday March 21st 2014 Will Hodgman Premier-Elect of Tasmania on behalf of the forest industry, and particularly on behalf of the special timbers industry, officially declared war on the Tasmanian community.

That was my immediate and clear response to this news item:

Does the special timbers industry want to be part of this war?

Does the special timbers industry want to be used and manipulated as the reason for this war?

As a member of the special timbers industry trying to establish a business to help move the industry onto private land and away from the politics and conflict of public forest management I certainly do not!


In the last 30 years I don’t recall the forestry wars being so formally declared, not with such blatant hostility and certainly not with the forest industry as reluctant (?) participants. Poor Terry Edwards (FIAT Chief Executive) standing behind Mr Hodgman looks more like a refugee trying to escape a warzone than a General about to lead what remains of his troops. “The world has moved on.” Indeed it has!

Some people think this is just a war against “the greenies” or those who failed to vote Liberal this time. But conflicts affect everyone. There are never winners in conflict; everyone loses, some more than others, often the innocent are the biggest losers. And the last 30 years of the forestry wars have been littered with false hopes and promises, and thousands of innocent victims. Politicians come and go while the victims are piled higher.

The losers over the last 30 years have been the forests, the forest industry and the Tasmanian community. That fact should be obvious to everyone. This time is no different.

Having spent last weekend as an exhibitor at the inaugural Deloraine Stringfest, it became very clear to me that this may have been the first and last Stringfest. Stringfest is a celebration of Tasmanias world-class timbers, the craftspeople who turn them into musical instruments, and the artists who play them. I was the only exhibitor representing the first link in the chain back to the trees and the people who grow them. That link needs to be strengthened and promoted. Farmers as proud tree growers need to become an integral part of Stringfest if it is to grow and have a sustainable future. There was no one at Stringfest representing Forestry Tasmania and public native forest management.

I spent the weekend at Stringfest wearing a black armband in mourning for the forest industry and the people of Tasmania.

Landmark events such as Stringfest and the Wooden Boat Festival, which showcase special timbers, will be used by our politicians as weapons to escalate the conflict. Even retailers, consumers and artists will be used as pawns in the battle.

The special timbers industry, whether it likes it or not, is being used as a weapon against the Tasmanian community. Talking to people at Stringfest there was a wide range of opinions within the industry. There was certainly no possibility for consensus on a future strategy. Many were resigned to the wars as passive observers. Some in the industry have already moved their supply sources onto private land in an attempt to avoid the conflict. A few are even looking forward to the coming battle in the hope that they will succeed. The last 30 years clearly show that outcome is very unlikely.

Many people have a “why don’t they….?” or “if only they would….” attitude to the problem. “The forests are there, if only we could manage them properly, then everything would be ok and everyone would be happy”. This fairytale dream just won’t happen. If anything the real world has moved in the opposite direction. The more people hold onto this fairytale the worse the nightmare becomes. In my opinion this fairytale has now become part of the problem. We need to give up the fairytale and move on.

Many people will not accept my interpretation of these events. That’s fine by me. People believe what they want to believe. Everyone has a different view on life.

Does the special timbers industry, including retailers, artists and consumers, want to be used and manipulated as the reason for this war?

What is more important?

Continuing to have access to conflict-ridden, unsustainable, taxpayer-subsidised special timbers from our public native forests, or moving the industry onto private land and bringing peace and prosperity to Tasmania?

For some in the special timbers industry this transition will be impossible, but for many it is a very real alternative. Many have already made the transition.

Please don’t be a pawn in Mr. Hodgman’s political power games. It is time to decide!

2 responses to “Black Friday

  1. Most professional guitarists are happy to play a guitar that has plain looking blackwood for back and sides if it sounds really good. Its easier to get a better sound with plain looking timber. This example already exists with Indian Rosewood. The sooner we can shift guitar making to plantation grown timber and convince players that it works the better it will be for the forest, Tasmanian politics and the future of the guitar making industry.
    Maton and Cole Clark already use plantation grown Queensland maple for their guitars. The Spruce suppliers of Europe grow spruce in plantations that are grown over more than one generation.
    Strato Anagnostis
    Australian Guitar Making School

    • Thanks Strato. And there is plenty of existing remnant “native” blackwood on private property in Tasmania that contains plain and highly figured blackwood as well. This needs to be better managed to improve its current and future value, in addition to growing commercial plantation blackwood – all part of my business plan.

      So the first “shift” is for tonewood merchants and luthiers to source their timber from farmers now – not “sooner”. Let’s build relationships with the farming community. Then once farmers see the opportunity they may decide to plant blackwood plantations, and better manage their existing tree resources.

      There are also remnants of myrtle and sassafras on private property that need to be positively managed. Not to mention the other timbers such as silver wattle, satinwood, tas oak. All good tonewoods. Huge existing and future potential.

      So all this can begin today! Right now!

      Luthiers! Contact your tonewood suppliers and tell them you only want Tasmanian timbers sourced from private land. Let’s get the market processes working for positive change.

      Tonewood merchants and sawmillers! You can either be at the farm gate or at the barracades in the next few years. I will leave that decision in your capable hands.

      Let’s take away Hodgman’s weapons of conflict.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s