The recent discussion about Bunya pine and the tonewood market led me to wonder about Queensland Hoop pine (Araucaria cunninghamii)
Hoop pine is the only premium plantation timber species currently harvested in Australia. Some 500 ha are harvested each year. It is not known how much wood is produced from this harvest.
As such Hoop pine provides the only example in Australia of what a future plantation blackwood market might look like; with the one exception that if I was around I would be trumpeting the blackwood market dynamics as much as possible. Market transparency is vital!
Here’s a Hoop pine fact sheet from the Queensland government:
http://era.daf.qld.gov.au/id/eprint/3931/4/hoop%20pine%20final%20factsheet_update%20May%202017.pdf
(Curious how these forest fact sheets never talk about economics or log prices, as if investing in trees has nothing to do with money!)
The 44,500 ha of Hoop pine plantations were established by the Queensland Government but were sold when the Government decided to privatise the forest plantation resource in 2010, and are now owned by the one company, Hancock Timber Resource Group, with the plantations managed by HQPlantations.
http://www.hqplantations.com.au/araucaria.html
So far as I’m aware the forest industry is not seeking to encourage the expansion of the Hoop pine plantation resource. Given that the Hoop pine owners pay no local Government rates, expansion of this resource by competing landowners will be difficult.
No one will ever know how much the market is paying for Hoop pine logs. It’s difficult enough to find Hoop pine timber retail prices. Timber merchants positively hate advertising their prices. So the economics of plantation Hoop pine as an investment are unknown and that’s the way the forest industry likes it.
If you spend a lot of time searching on the internet you may find the following economic study of plantation hoop pine investment:
Herbohn, J.L. 2006, ‘Potential financial returns from Hoop Pine and an assessment of the likely impacts of various support measures on landholder willingness to plant’, in Harrison, S.R. and Herbohn, J.L (ed.), Proceedings of Sustainable Forest Industry Development in Tropical North Queensland; Cooperative Research Centre for Tropical Rainforest Ecology and Management, Rainforest CRC, Cairns.
Herbohn 2006
The study uses a stumpage of just $70 per cubic metre for a 45-50 year-old plantation grown premium wood product!!
That would certainly kill any landholder willingness to plant!
All a 2012 Queensland Government report on the State forest industry could say about Hoop pine was these 60 words:
Araucaria (hoop pine) plantations consist largely of plantings of hoop pine (Araucaria cunninghamii), with smaller areas of bunya pine (Araucaria bidwillii). However, araucaria log timber is relatively costly to produce because of high management and harvesting inputs, largely as a result of the steep sites on which it has been established and high pruning costs. Crop rotation lengths are also very long at around 40 to 50 years.
State of Queensland (2012) Queensland forest and timber industry situation analysis.
It doesn’t sound encouraging does it?
Nevertheless I managed to track down one Hoop pine retail price list:
It’s a curious price list in terms of the limited sizes available and the prices. High prices for small cuts but not for big cuts. Wide boards (140mm) are cheaper, with thicker wide boards (31mm) being cheaper than thin boards (12mm). The prices on the range of 42mm wide boards (8, 19, 31 and 42 mm) provides for some curious deliberation.
What is clear is that these represent premium prices (~$9,000 per cubic metre) for premium plantation timber. Compare these prices with the $2,500 per cubic metre for dressed premium grade Radiata pine from Bunnings Hardware:
https://blackwoodgrowers.com.au/2016/07/01/bunnings-timber-price-lists/
It would certainly be interesting to know the details of the business model the Hoop pine plantation owner uses to maximise returns to the company. Just exactly how profitable are these plantations to the owner? This price list gives us few clues.
If any readers have Hoop pine growing I’d love to hear your stories. Send us a comment.
Tasmanian Blackwood Growers Cooperative 
Guitar Makers Challenged by New Rosewood Restrictions—and What This Means for Players
This article appeared in the August 2017 issue of Acoustic Guitar magazine. It makes for interesting reading.
http://acousticguitar.com/guitar-makers-challenged-by-new-rosewood-restrictions-and-what-it-means-for-players/
It doesn’t provide much in the way of new information, but gives insight into the challenges the guitar industry is facing in a rapidly changing tonewood market, and the different responses.
So will the price of rosewood tonewood increase as a result of the new CITES restrictions?
Of course it will!
As supplies of illegal rosewood become restricted the demand for Indian rosewood will increase. Indian rosewood supply will not increase in the short term so price must go up. The basic laws of economics.
Guitar makers are caught between a guitar-buying public that is resistant to alternative species and a shrinking supply of traditional tonewoods.
But anyone who goes to any guitar maker’s website will see plenty of images and products made from rare and exotic tonewoods. Try and find the word “sustainable” on these websites!
The guitar industry does not seem to be terribly serious about the problem.
Bedell Guitars are one of the few standout examples of a company that is trying hard to build a sustainable tonewood future and pushing the market in that direction. Their website is pretty good.
http://bedellguitars.com/
Bedell still believe that logging rainforest and oldgrowth is sustainable and where their future is; unlike Taylor Guitars who are making the move towards plantation tonewoods.
“When it comes to alternatives [tonewoods], there’s much more likelihood of supply chains being erratic in terms of quality and supply.”
Given that most of the world’s forests have been systematically plundered this is not surprising.
The guitar industry needs to start from scratch and help replant and grow new tonewood resources. Taylor Guitars are doing this. It’s time for the rest of the industry to get on board.
Tasmanian farmers are waiting to hear from the tonewood market.
Tasmanian blackwood – the [potentially] sustainable tonewood.
2 Comments
Posted in Commentary, Markets, Tonewood